Garage Door Dilemma: To Franchise or Not to Franchise?

The Rabbit Hole of Decisions

Yeah, sorry it’s me and the garage doors again. Picture this: you’ve been listening to too many podcasts and now you’ve decided to get into the garage door business. You’re itching to do a mini-rollup, but thinking maybe you should establish a “platform” first by buying a franchise? And you know you can get pretty much any franchise disclosure free from the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions (DFI). So you download a representative FDD.

Do you buy a franchise, or do you take the independent route by purchasing an existing garage door service company?

Both options have pros and cons, but as with many life-altering decisions, it’s less like choosing between Coke and Pepsi and more like deciding whether to live on Mars or the Moon. Both are viable options, but the details make all the difference.

Let’s unpack this.

The Franchise Wonderland

Franchises are like Ikea furniture: you get a blueprint, tools, and instructions to build something that looks great (as long as you don’t deviate). But — and this is a big “but” — you don’t own the design. It’s Ikea’s world; you just live in it.

With a franchise, the business comes with:

• A recognizable brand name. (hopefully in your market)
• Training wheels (operational guidelines, training, and support).
• A network of approved vendors and marketing systems.

Sounds great, right? Well, it is — until you read the fine print.

Rulebook of Doom

The Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) I came across on the DFI site was a thrilling novel of restrictions, financial obligations, and legalese. Here are the highlights (or lowlights, depending on your mood):

1. You’re Never Really the Boss: They must approve everything — who you sell to, what vendors you use, and even what’s on your truck. Want to innovate? Too bad.
2. Ongoing Fees Galore: Say hello to royalties (6% of gross sales or $150 weekly minimum) and marketing fund contributions. These fees gnaw away at your profits like a hungry trash panda (that’s a racoon in case you didn’t know)
3. Exit Strategy? Not So Fast: Selling the franchise isn’t simple. You need permission, a transfer fee, and they can even swoop in with a right of first refusal. Oh, and you might still be on the hook for warranties sold before you leave.

This specific FDD had a shaky legal history. Cue the red flags.

The Independent Route: Freedom with a Dash of Risk

On the other side of our forked road lies the dream of independence. Buying an existing garage door service company gives you:

• Full control over operations, pricing, and strategy.
• No royalties or mandatory fees.
• An established customer base and local reputation.

It’s like inheriting a fully furnished house instead of starting with a bare plot of land. But, as with any good deal, there’s a catch. You’ll need to:

• Thoroughly vet the business’s financials (no one likes surprise debts).
• Negotiate a fair purchase price.
• Ensure the business’s reputation is as shiny as the doors it services.

Head-to-Head: Franchise vs. Independent

Here’s where we get nerdy with comparisons:

The Decision Framework

So, what should you do? Well, let’s think it through:

Go Franchise If:

• You’re new to the industry and need a proven system to follow.
• You value the instant credibility of a national brand.
• You’re okay with ongoing fees in exchange for support.

Go Independent If:

• You want full control over your business.
• You’re savvy enough to assess a business’s health and negotiate deals.
• You’d rather keep your profits than share them with a franchisor.

Let’s zoom out for a second. This decision isn’t just about garage doors — it’s a microcosm of the great existential debate: freedom vs. security.

A franchise is like being on a cruise ship: you get a structured experience, planned meals, and safety nets. And you probably won’t be able to pull off a “mini-rollup”. An independent business is like buying your own boat. It’s riskier, but you can sail wherever you want (or end up shipwrecked — it’s up to you).

The real question is: What kind of captain do you want to be?

Wrapping Up

If it were me? I’d lean toward buying an independent business. Why? Because freedom, autonomy, and the ability to maximize profits outweigh the initial safety net of a franchise.

But hey, that’s just me. What about you? Which side of the fork are you taking, Captain?

Do you have a business you need help selling? Click here.